Our custom birthday cakes can be prepared to your specifications and themed to fit any age party.

Custom cakes may be booked from 1-4 weeks in advance. Did you procrastinate on your order? We have dessert cakes that are basic, non-themed cakes that can be prepared in 72 hours. (Please remember we are closed Sunday and Monday so dessert cake orders for Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday pickup must be placed by 4:00 pm on Saturday when we close for the weekend.) Also, so that you don’t procrastinate next time, join our cake club and we will send you an email reminder to order early!

Custom Cake Options

Party Cake FAQs

Yes! We rent our cake and cupcake stands for $40 for the weekend. We have a variety of cupcake towers and cake plateaus in gold, silver, pearl, and wood.

No. We do not ship our cakes at this time.

Yes! We offer delivery within Tulsa and surrounding communities, please call us to receive a delivery quote.

If you provide a swatch, we will do our best to match the color. However, please keep in mind that due to food coloring limitations, we may not be able to guarantee an exact match. Color swatches should be delivered to All Things Cake when ordering your cake. Swatches sent via email or text are not reliable given differences in screens and printers.

We currently offer gluten-free cakes in chocolate and vanilla. Our icing and fondant is also gluten free. We do not currently offer sugar free, nut free, dairy free or egg free.

Yes! As long as you keep your cake refrigerated, your cake will stay fresh for up to 5 days.

Yes, you will want to refrigerate your cake until 1 hour before serving.

Our cakes are priced based on the size (number of servings) and how it’s decorated. Our cakes can be created in any of our flavor and filling combinations. We do not charge extra for different flavors/fillings.

No, you can place your cake order by calling us at 918-994-4490 or by coming into the store during regular business hours.

Changes to party cakes can be made up until 1 week before pick up. After that time, changes will be evaluated and may be available for an additional fee.

Party cakes require a 50% non-refundable deposit. The remaining balance on cakes being picked up can be paid at time of pick up. Cakes being delivered must be paid in full prior to delivery.

Wedding cakes require a 30% non-refundable deposit. The remaining balance is due 3 weeks before the delivery date.

While we are open Tuesday-Saturday, we only allow custom cake pick-ups Wednesday-Friday from 10am-5pm and Saturdays from 10am-4pm.

Advance order is required for both custom cakes and dessert cakes. We recommend ordering 2-3 weeks in advance for custom cakes and at least 4 days in advance for dessert cakes. Some custom fondant accents need extra time to dry, so please keep that in mind if your design requires sculpted fondant work.

Let All Things Cake host your next birthday party! Our Cupcake Wars Birthday Party is perfect for ages 7+ and lasts 90 minutes.  Teams will compete to create cupcakes in a theme and win cool prizes!  Our party host will take over the minute you walk in the door.  We will lead the guests through decorating 1 dozen cupcakes with buttercream, piping bags, edibles and sprinkles. Next, we will serve cake and drinks, open gifts, and have guests sign the souvenir apron for the birthday child!

  • 1 dozen cupcakes for each guest
  • All tools & supplies
  • Party ware
  • 8” round cake to serve
  • Souvenir apron
  • Candles
  • Juice & water
  • Prizes
  • Set up & clean up
  • Gift tracking list
Cupcake Party $349 / 12 guests
$30 / add’l guest